Who sings "She Loves You Yea Yea Yea" on All You Need Is Love?

I've had a few changes of thought, but this is the new conclusion I came up with. Maybe one of you could so kindly confirm or suppress this:

First, I thought it was John, because on the AYNIL video, you see John singing, which should be proof enough.

Then I realized that Paul was actually movnig his mouth too, which made me think, "Eh? So who's singing this?"

Well, I did some research on the What Goes On website and other places, and have come to this conclusion:

The "Woah yea!" at the end is definitely Paul, during the "Love is all you need" coda.

The SAME voice sings, "Loves You yea yea yea" afterward. Not to mention that John JUST finished singing, "Love is all you need." and wouldn't be able to take a big enough breath to do that.

However, you DO hear John's cracking voice during the second, "She'd love to, yea yea yea" which signals that John joins in, and it becomes Paul and John.


Is this a sound theory? Seems like it makes sense.

I agree. I watched the video and I came to the conclusion that they both sing it.

[ QUOTE ]
justanothergirl Posted:
I agree. I watched the video and I came to the conclusion that they both sing it.

[/ QUOTE ] It's both of them. I can hear both of their voices at the same time.

I've analyzed this many times..it's definetly John singing at the end. And remember, they were singing to some vocals that had been pre-recorded, so that's how John is able to sing w/o taking a breath.

John...no, Paul...maybe John...definitley both...Deja vu
I like to think ti is both of them

[ QUOTE ]
pepperland67 Posted:
I've analyzed this many times..it's definetly John singing at the end. And remember, they were singing to some vocals that had been pre-recorded, so that's how John is able to sing w/o taking a breath.

[/ QUOTE ]i agree with pep67

It's John. The take that we hear on record was mostly (I'm assuming) the live version. That's why you can hear John chewing gum in the beginning, somebody saying something that sounds much like "check it", and Pauls tongue roll towards the end. And, of course, John singing the She Loves You chorus. All of these things can be seen happening (besides the "check it" thing) in the video of the live recording.

Ok, I just finished watching it to verify. It is John singing. You can see Paul mouthing it after John has already started, but it is the sound of John's voice that you are hearing.

It's Ringo, you guys. Duh.

Ringo would really struggle hitting that high note.

Personally, I think Paul went "Oh yea!" then started with "She loves you..." then John joined in for the 'Yea, yea, yea". Then they both did it the second time.

Of course, if you listen carefully, they're not actually singing "She loves you yea, yea, yea", they actually singing "We loved you yea, yea, yea." Listen to it now!

I'm sure I've posted this before...

If you listen to the full 'Our World' version, you'll hear John sing 'She Loves You' etc at the end of the take which they subsequently sang along to for the broadcast - so my answer to your question is John, John, John and John, not forgetting John, but mainly john.

I'm sure I've posted this before...

[ QUOTE ]
Harbidge Posted:
Ringo would really struggle hitting that high note.

Personally, I think Paul went "Oh yea!" then started with "She loves you..." then John joined in for the 'Yea, yea, yea". Then they both did it the second time.

Of course, if you listen carefully, they're not actually singing "She loves you yea, yea, yea", they actually singing "We loved you yea, yea, yea." Listen to it now!

[/ QUOTE ]

That's even a Paul Is Dead clue! ^_^

Me, incintuated with Paul is Dead?

Never!

[ QUOTE ]
Harbidge Posted:
Me, incintuated with Paul is Dead?

Never!

[/ QUOTE ]

I'm not, and I don't go to this site: http://macca4ever.proboards26.com/index.cgi

I'd never go on a site that is in competition with a PID site! EVER!

It's John...I've watched that video many many times...and I'm pretty positive it's John.

[ QUOTE ]
BeatleBabe21 Posted:
It's John...I've watched that video many many times...and I'm pretty positive it's John.

[/ QUOTE ]

That's the thing -- I have myself, and I see that Paul was singing it too, it's just that some guy blocked his face for a bit at the beginning. But the voice that sings "Woah yea" is definitely the voice that sings, "Loves you, yea yea yea"

I read it was Paul who slipped in that retro bonus treat and it even sounds like Paul.

lol the mystery that will never be solved. It is astonishing when you consider that both Paul and John supposedly have distinct voices...

Another mystery that was once brought up on Blinks is who is the second voice that sings "Look!" , "I'm" and "Please!" in What You're Doing?

[ QUOTE ]
It is astonishing when you consider that both Paul and John supposedly have distinct voices...

[/ QUOTE ] Yes, and I've said it back then a hundreds of times, and I say it now. The Oh yeah and first time She loves You, always sounded like Paul to me, nothing at all like John. Shorty afterwards John joins in and they sing it together.

[ QUOTE ]
Legs Posted:
[ QUOTE ]
It is astonishing when you consider that both Paul and John supposedly have distinct voices...

[/ QUOTE ] Yes, and I've said it back then a hundreds of times, and I say it now. The Oh yeah and first time She loves You, always sounded like Paul to me, nothing at all like John. Shorty afterwards John joins in and they sing it together.

[/ QUOTE ]

It always sounded like a single voice to me singing the "She Loves You Yeah Yeah Yeah" part.