BeatleLinks Fab Forum

BeatleLinks Fab Forum (
-   I Read The News Today (
-   -   Apple is Suing Apple Computers Again (

shyGirl Sep 11, 2003 10:26 PM

Apple is Suing Apple Computers Again,2933,97064,00.html

The inevitable has happened: The Beatles have sued Steve Jobs over Apple iTunes and the Apple iPod -- at least the band's company, Apple Corps., has sued Apple Computers.

The case was apparently filed a short time ago in London's High Court of Justice, but was just served on Apple Computers in California in the last couple of days. Although details from the court papers aren't yet available, the gist of the breach of contract suit is as follows.

When Apple Computers first came into existence, the Beatles' lawyers sued -- and won -- over the use of the corporate name. The Fab Four, it was widely known, already had their own company called Apple Corps. (Ironically, Jobs admitted to naming his company as a tribute to the Beatles.) The result of the suit was a huge cash settlement and a promise that the Apple logo and name would only be used for computers -- and never for a music company.

Several years later, when computers starting having music come through attachable speakers, the Beatles again sued and won, this time over breach of a trademark agreement since Apple Computers had agreed to steer clear of the music business. Their winnings against Apple Computers have come to an estimated $50 million so far.

When Jobs announced the iPod portable music player and companion music site iTunes, this column was the first to mention that the computer company could be in serious violation of its agreement with the Beatles. Now it appears that the Beatles' lawyers, Eversheds of London, are in agreement.

"When it first happened with the iPod, we said, "What could they be thinking?" said a Beatles legal insider, who agreed that posters announcing the iPod from "AppleMusic" were among the most egregious violations. "They knew we had the agreement, and that we'd won a lot of money from them already."

A call by this column to Apple Computers' legal counsel, Nancy Heinen, was refused this afternoon. But my Beatles source said, "It's OK with us if they want to go this route. It's just more money for us."

lennonluvr9 Sep 12, 2003 04:11 AM

Re: Apple is Suing Apple Computers Again
Aww geez....

HMVNipper Sep 12, 2003 09:00 AM

Re: Apple is Suing Apple Computers Again
The truly ironic thing here is that nowadays if you ask the average joe on the street (not Beatles fans) what they associate the corporate name "Apple" with, they will invariably say it's a computer. Perhaps it was a bigger deal when the Apple Computer was a new thing and the Beatles' company was more in the general public eye, but today? Very few people outside of the music industry or the community of Beatles fans even associate "Apple" with "music" (unless they're talking about an iPod, ironically!).

Surely there must be a way to resolve this in some other manner?

Legs Sep 12, 2003 09:42 AM

Re: Apple is Suing Apple Computers Again
Then Apple (The Beatles one) did something wrong from the beginning, they should have prohibiited the use of the Apple name.

All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:33 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.